Informa present at the 9th Spanish Forestry Congress

At the 9th Spanish Forestry Congress, our colleague, Celia Yagüe, attended the session MR9: “The value of ecosystem services, carbon credits and biodiversity,” organized by the Forest and Climate Change Forum (Foro de Bosques y Cambio Climático).

This session was divided into four thematic round tables, which addressed the latest developments in the national forest carbon credit market, from the new European framework, currently being developed, to the amendment of the Royal Decree on Carbon Footprint, including proposals for new Enhanced Forest Management methodologies in various projects, such as ECO2FOR and HE SMURF (sister project).

«I would highlight the wealth of perspectives provided by representatives of different key stakeholders: forest owners, public managers, and promoters of forest carbon sinks on the latest developments and some advances in the development of biodiversity credits», stated Celia.

Some key quotes by thematic round table/stakeholder:

  • Round table 1 – Public institutions / Regulators:
    “We are building a European and national regulatory framework that guarantees traceability, additionality, and sustainability as the basis for the credibility of carbon markets.”
  • Table 2 – Research, technical centres, and certifiers:
    “Developing rigorous methodologies that are adapted to the Spanish context and viable for small landowners is key to democratizing access to absorption markets.”
  • Table 3 – Project developers/forestry companies:
    “The challenge lies in making absorption projects based on adaptive sustainable forest management (ASFM) viable, scalable, and sustainable in a market that is still immature and has high costs compared to other countries.”
  • Table 4 – Forest owners and public managers:
    “Carbon markets represent a real opportunity to finance sustainable forest management in Spanish forests, but they require administrative simplification and reliable quantification methodologies to gain trust.”

For those working on restoration, carbon sequestration, or ecosystem services projects, this session was a real roadmap of the current state of the sector in Europe and Spain.

Overcoming knowledge gaps in soil science and Voluntary Carbon Markets

Although soils contain larger amounts of carbon than standing biomass, such as trees and plants, soils are rarely considered in forest management decisions concerning forest carbon or in carbon voluntary markets. Wide knowledge gaps exist for forest carbon, both in terms of cost-efficient monitoring methodologies and whether current forest management decisions are good or bad for forest soils and the amount of carbon they store.

The current EU Carbon Removals & Carbon Farming Certification (CRCF) regulation does not yet include soil carbon, but it probably will in its 5-year revision, hence there is a rush to fill the gap with collaborative and scientifically-based results.

To tackle this issue, in Catalonia, the Agricultural Department is setting up a living lab on Soil Health under the framework of the EU soil mission, to which the INFORMA partner CPF is contributing. In the last group meeting, held on 25 October, the work carried out by INFORMA’s KU Leuven team, led by Prof. Dr. Bart Muys and Dr. Ilié Storms, was presented.

In September 2024, the Belgian team, accompanied by the project’s technical coordinator Celia Yagüe, from the Polytechnic University of Valencia (UPV), also visited Catalonia to carry out fieldwork in managed and unmanaged forest stands in collaboration with Catalan stakeholders, which included members of the CTFC (Forest Science and Technology Centre of Catalonia) working on the Horizon project HoliSoils. Together they discussed the best methodologies to estimate soil carbon in Mediterranean forests, especially if the effects of forest management on soil carbon are to be assessed.

To learn more about the topic, watch the video interview below with CPF’s Teresa Baiges, a researcher active both in INFORMA and HoliSoils:

Protecting forest carbon stocks in the Mediterranean: INFORMA’s contribution to the Climate Credit System of Catalonia

Climate change, water scarcity and biodiversity decline are challenges that go hand in hand in the Mediterranean Region, mutually reinforcing each other. This principle holds true in INFORMA’s case study region in Catalonia, the Segre-Rialb basin, where climate change is not only increasing the risk of mega-fires – which threaten important forest carbon stocks – but also the danger of water shortages due to extended periods of drought. Forest management can work as a nature-based solution, contributing to climate adaptation, water regulation and biodiversity protection.

In this context, the Government of Catalonia is developing several integrative solutions to engage small forest owners in forest management activities that lower the vulnerability of forests. One of those was the creation of a new voluntary credit system of unique “Climate credits” in 2023, to which INFORMA is contributing.

Rather than just focusing on carbon, the new climate credits jointly consider the provision of different ecosystem services, such as carbon sequestration, blue water availability and biodiversity conservation. This system is meant to be applied to forest, agricultural and aquatic environments and has already been launched for the forestry sector. For that, a methodology was developed within the Life Climark project.

The Climate Credit System of Catalonia includes a broad set of forestry practices that go beyond tree planting and are context-adapted, such as thinnings that integrate biodiversity conservation measures or fire prevention measures in strategic areas. Currently, Catalonia has 10 adaptation and mitigation forestry projects in the pipeline that are beginning to be financed through the new system.

The Catalan system is now finalising its internal protocols, such as the final list of eligible Improved Forest Management practices, MRV methodologies, and its alignment with the European Carbon Removals & Carbon Farming Certification (CRCF), among others. INFORMA has been actively contributing to this process by providing information and insights to fine-tune and further develop the protocols.

The work, led by the Forest Ownership Centre (CPF), an INFORMA partner, is carried out on two fronts: joint participatory research on modelling and best monitoring methodologies (remote sensing and on-field techniques), and participating in focus group discussions to make Mediterranean voices heard in the process. Regarding this latest point, different focus groups are being organised by the INFORMA project partner I4CE throughout 2024 and 2025. Results will be presented at the Carbon Farming Summit in Dublin in March 2025,  as well as in the European CRCF group of experts where I4CE is an official member.

This work will also feed into INFORMA’s general recommendations to enhance the contribution of Improved Forest Management to carbon markets at the European level, making sure the southern Europe specificities are considered.

Training sites for knowledge transfer and outreach

Connecting to INFORMA’s work on the topics of carbon credits and forest management, two new training areas are being established in Catalonia’s counties of Alt Penedes and La Garrotxa with the support of the European Forest Institute (EFI). They include demonstration plots and training sites known as marteloscopes, where the effect of forest management decisions can be simulated in real time.

The Catalan marteloscopes belong to the European Integrate Network of marteloscopes, facilitated by  EFI. The training areas aim to broaden the debate on the role of fire prevention and post-fire management in carbon balances, as well as on the need to develop new value chains for long-life forest products, where carbon is stored on a more permanent basis, compared to alternative short-life products such as firewood, pallets or biomass for energy.

The marteloscopes will also help to convey new knowledge obtained by INFORMA to interested stakeholders, such as different pathways for forest management under climate change, depending on the forest manager’s goals and objectives.

Banner photo: Thomas Baertl

New paper: The effects of forest fires on postfire land surface warming

What happens to forests hit by wildfires after the flames are gone?

While the immediate impacts of wildfires are a hot topic in the media, post-fire effects on land management are less frequently discussed. Fires not only release carbon and other particles into the atmosphere but also influence energy and water exchanges between land and air, which can impact local climates.

New research, supported by INFORMA, reveals that bigger fires lead to warmer land surface temperatures. This warming effect is more pronounced in areas dominated by coniferous trees, which are more vulnerable to fire than broadleaf trees. In regions with a higher proportion of broadleaf trees, which are less flammable, the warming effect was reduced.

As northern forests are expected to experience larger fires in the future, the authors suggest adopting climate-smart forestry practices. Climate-smart forestry with more broadleaf trees can help mitigate local climate warming effects, and have a positive influence on forest regeneration.

Curious to learn more? Dive into the full open-access study «Forest fire size amplifies postfire land surface warming«, published in Nature and supported by our partner Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam!

Zhao, J., Yue, C., Wang, J. et al. Forest fire size amplifies postfire land surface warming. Nature 633, 828–834 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-07918-8

Integrating Forest Management into Carbon Certification: Where Are We and How to Move Forward?

Improving forest carbon projects isn’t just about technology. State-of-the-art sensors and monitoring techniques are important, but so are smarter guidelines and solid methodologies. Curious how?

Our experts at the Institute for Climate Economics have laid out recommendations to better integrate forest management practices into carbon certification—while steering clear of pitfalls like overcrediting. Here’s a quick rundown of their main pieces of advice:

  • Most projects focus on afforestation or avoiding deforestation, but carbon schemes can diversify by including everyday practices like risk management and stand thinning when it leads to additional forest growth.
  • Accurate baselines are essential, as weaknesses in baseline design and validation are some of the biggest loopholes leading to carbon offset scandals.
  • Climate impacts, like fires and droughts, can be factored in through larger buffer pools, ensuring carbon permanence after credits are issued.
  • Looking beyond carbon: While most carbon projects also take into account other sustainability issues, each methodology sets its own rules. Guidelines for integrating and measuring other ecosystem services are important to ensure better consistency and give financiers more clarity.

To learn more, check out our new factsheet:

Faced with the Climate Crisis, How Will Forest Owners and Managers Adapt?

How are Europe’s forest managers and owners adapting to climate change? INFORMA conducted a survey to find out, compiling 237 responses from eight countries: Romania, Spain, France, Germany, Belgium, Netherlands, Finland and the Republic of Moldova.

The results indicate that forest management decisions on climate change adaptation involve differences in values, beliefs,
knowledge, risk perceptions, desired objectives, issues of trust and prior experiences among forest managers. Forest owners and managers are highly aware of climate change effects on the forests they manage, and two thirds of them think forests will be significantly affected by it.

Here are some of our other main findings:

  • 75% of forest managers identified forest fires as a major vulnerability in the future
  • While forest managers expect a decline in forest productivity, more respondents are concerned about biodiversity loss than about timber production.
  • Most forest managers believe natural regeneration will become more difficult in their region.
  • About 30% of forest managers said they have changed species selection criteria to anticipate climate-change impacts, while more than half did not change the way they select the species for planting.
  • Traditional mindsets, workforce shortages, training needs, bureaucracy, economic or administrative obstacles were considered some of the biggest barriers to climate adaptation.

Read the full results in our new factsheet by USV researchers Laura Bouriaud and Ramona Scriban:

Developing Long-life Wood Uses to Improve Carbon Storage: Where Are We in Europe?

Directing more wood towards long-life products such as panels and insulation materials can help us maximise carbon sinks without increasing forest harvests. That’s because these products store carbon for a longer periods of time in form of long-lasting construction and renovation materials. But for this to happen in practice, more market opportunities and production capacity are needed. How can public policies help?

Our latest study dives into the wood sector policies of France, Germany, Romania, and Sweden to find out. These are our main takeaways:

  1. Subsidizing long-life wood uses can help boost demand and production. Germany, for example, subsidized bio-based insulation (including wood fibre insulation) to cover half of the additional cost of the original product. This strategy led the volume of bio-based insulation products entering the German market to a fifty-fold increase, which ultimately allowed subsidies to be discontinued while maintaining production.
  2. Prioritizing wood uses through public policies helps hit specific targets. Different policy choices have encouraged the development of panel production, and others were more geared towards energy or the production of paper pulp. In practice, these other wood uses compete for the same resources as certain long-life wood products. Thus, there is a need to establish trade-offs and prioritise certain uses.
  3. Developing the furniture sector boosts the supply of semi-finished products. Although furniture does not store carbon for as long as construction and renovation materials, the furniture industry can help to scale up the production of these products, which can also be used in construction.

    Check out all the details in this new factsheet by our I4CE researchers Océane Le Pierrès and Julia Grimault and by INRAE’s Valentin Bellassen:

    Innovation in Knowledge Transfer: Applying the Research-Integration-Utilisation Model

    In the context of the INFORMA project, the Universitat Politècnica de València (UPV), in Spain, has strengthened ties with its partners at the Georg-August Universität Göttingen (UGOE), Germany. On 10th July, the UPV coordinating team visited UGOE to strengthen cooperation in knowledge transfer, an area in which UGOE has made significant progress with its innovative RIU (Research-Integration-Utilisation) model.

    During the visit, it was discussed in depth how this model can be integrated into the different work streams of the INFORMA project. This approach has shown to be essential to identify and analyse the power relations and interests of the stakeholders involved in forest management, as well as to understand social perception of sustainable forest management (SFM). These meetings allow project partners to align their strategies and approaches, ensuring that science-based solutions are effectively transferred into practice.

    Jose-Vicente Oliver, UPV coordinator for INFORMA, addressed the challenge of forest fires in the Mediterranean region, highlighting the abandonment of rural-forestry activity exacerbated by the climate crisis. Marta Esteve presented the preliminary results of a survey on the social perception of SFM, focusing on the Valencian Region. These presentations underlined the need to adapt models such as RIU to the specific context of the Mediterranean, which presents unique challenges and opportunities compared to other regions in Europe.

    Michael Kirchener, representing UGOE, explained how the RIU model facilitates the transfer of scientific information to different societal groups. This model focuses on three key components: the production of scientific information, its integration through exchange forums, and its use by stakeholders. ‘Integration fora’ are formal or informal spaces where stakeholders can exchange science-based information. The identification of these fora and the assessment of stakeholders’ interests and powers is crucial for the effective implementation of the model.

    The UPV researchers José-Vicente Oliver, Celia Yagüe and Marta Esteve

    The Social-Milieu Concept

    The term ‘social-milieu’ or social environment refers to the context in which individuals develop, considering aspects such as living conditions, work, economy, income level and education. This concept encompasses more than just social class, as it includes relationships and interactions with various people and institutions in everyday life. Individuals within the same social environment often share values, behavioural patterns and a sense of solidarity, which facilitates socialisation and the exchange of ideas.

    In the INFORMA project, social-milieu analysis is central to understanding how different social groups perceive and relate to forest management. By better understanding these contexts, the project aims to adapt its communication and knowledge transfer strategies to be more effective and culturally sensitive, especially when it comes to decision-making.

    The meeting concluded with an exchange of ideas and a passionate debate on the applicability of the RIU model in the Mediterranean context. Participants agreed that, despite regional differences, there are commonalities that can be exploited to improve management and knowledge transfer in the forestry sector.

    This type of collaboration and continuous dialogue is essential to advance research and the implementation of effective forestry policies, adapted to local needs and realities. The INFORMA project thus continues its mission to promote sustainable forest management through cooperation and knowledge exchange.

    Making Science Results Count for Practitioners: Our contribution to the Fire in the Earth Congress

    By Doan Ho, Climate-KIC

    Last month, my Climate-KIC colleague Dr Saskia Keesstra and I journeyed to Caceres, a sunbaked UNESCO World Heritage town of 100,000 in the remote region of Spanish Extremadura. I say remote because all trains were cancelled to the entire region for 6 days a mere 3 days before I needed them, which meant that I took a scenic 4-hour bus from Madrid after my Amsterdam-Madrid flight. Saskia was already in Valencia and opted to test out her new camper van by driving the 650 kilometres cross-country.

    We met in Caceres for the third international Congress on Fire in the Earth System, a conference on all things concerning fire, including its effects on land management, society and economy, politics, as well as soil and water. Despite the particularities of physically getting to the region, the conference was extremely well organised. Conferences of this sort always seek to create synergies between researchers, policymakers, practitioners, and citizens. And they always try to contribute to new approaches to X subject – simply insert fire research in our case. But the uniqueness of the location created a group of attendees who really wanted to be there, instead of using the conference as CV fodder, something you might not get if you had held the conference in Madrid. The conversations were memorable, fruitful, and very honest.

    Saskia and I came to Caceres to give a presentation about exploring the crucial role of stakeholder integration in forest and wildfire management within the context of the Horizon Europe INFORMA project. The latest scientific findings indicate that improved sustainable forest management practices can double forests’ climate change mitigation impact by 2050. INFORMA is attempting to deploy a holistic approach to bridge the gap between practitioners working on the ground, scientists, policymakers, carbon markets, and civil society at large.

    Generally, a lot of research is being funded and undertaken, but the trick is then translating those quantitative results into concrete policy recommendations for governments, as well as translating science into something to which practitioners and citizens can relate.

    If an ecologist spoke about their work to a geneticist, they would hardly understand. You can imagine the even larger gulf of understanding when the ecologist speaks to the average Joe or their mayor. This is where ‘science brokerage’ comes in, a counterintuitive fancy term social scientists use to describe methods to translate very technical science to non-technical people. What social scientists mean is that insight of non-scientists during the actual research process is crucial to making science practical.

    When the whole “quadruple helix” is well-informed and involved in research from the very beginning, the societal and government willingness to uptake new policy recommendations or new scientific results is increased. The quadruple helix is once again an obfuscating social science term for the overlapping interactions between four sectors: 1) universities, 2) industry, 3) government/policymakers, and 4) civil society/NGOs.

    We gave a comprehensive overview of INFORMA’s process of using stakeholder mapping and stakeholder engagement in shaping forest management practices and wildfire resilience. The first step we took in INFORMA was stakeholder mapping, which is a process used to guide knowledge transfer and integration of research into society. Who do we know, how, and to what extent? Only when we can map that, can we know how to involve these actors into the research and in policy implementation later. This is one way to create buy-in for the research and the subsequent policy recommendations from forest owners, forest practitioners, policymakers, and carbon certification providers.

    Step two was creating workshops with these aforementioned actors to build a relationship, create the communication channels, create that buy-in, and receive crucial feedback for our research in the real world. The workshops were also meant to foster conversations between this quadruple helix interested in forest management and forest carbon certification so they can learn from each other’s perspectives and pain points. Step three will be creating working groups that meet every 6 weeks to road test the carbon certification innovations that our research has provided using the relationships that we’ve built in step one and two.

    After a lot of sitting in an auditorium and attempting to wrap my head around very technical LIDAR maps and chemistry science – as a social scientist, my brain was melting a bit – we were treated to a lot of cardio. The wonderful conference organisers brought us to Monfrague National Park, one of Europe’s last unspoiled ecosystems; the Jerte Valley where I bought 15 kilos of local cherries; and a few gorgeous peaks in the Sierra de las Villuercas. As you can imagine, the physical scientists and geologists were quite agile hauling themselves up and down the mountainsides. Note to social scientists (read: me): spend less time at your desk and do more cardio if you want to keep up.

    Research results: iPad mobile laser scanning can help assess forest carbon stocks, but is more effective in mature, regular stands

    By Arne Van Wolputte, KU Leuven

    Measuring the amount of plant material (biomass) in forests is important for two main reasons: it helps us understand how climate change is affecting forests, and it allows us to calculate how much carbon these forests are absorbing, which helps counteract and offset emissions. In a previous blog post, we introduced the research of KU Leuven MSc student Arne Van Wolputte, exploring the transition from traditional aboveground biomass assessment methods to innovative, digital techniques such as mobile laser scanning. We also discussed the potential of the novel Arboreal Forest iPad app to make carbon Monitoring, Reporting and Verification effective and affordable while maintaining its simplicity. In this new article, Arne presents the results of his investigation, looking at how his use of the app in biomass inventorying affected the accuracy and efficiency of biomass measurements.

    —-

    Accurately assessing above-ground biomass in forests is crucial for understanding the impacts of climate change and quantifying carbon sequestration in offsetting projects. Traditional forest inventory methods, involving a tape measure and height estimation devices, are accurate but time-consuming and expensive to conduct. The integration of laser scanning technology into commercial devices, such as the iPad Pro, presents a promising avenue for the forestry sector to reduce inventory costs. These systems offer the potential to efficiently and accurately assess biomass while ensuring accessibility for stakeholders.

    We explored the transition from traditional methods to Arboreal Forest, a forest inventory app with laser scanning functionality, in two forest environments covered by the INFORMA project’s case studies: the Atlantic and Mediterranean biogeographic regions.

    Main findings

    Our findings revealed that the Arboreal Forest app’s effectiveness varied depending on the forest environment. In the Atlantic case study, measuring the above-ground biomass took about 60 minutes per plot with the traditional method, while only 16 minutes were required when Arboreal Forest was used. The biomass estimations by Arboreal Forest were nearly as accurate as those observed with traditional tools, with a 0.58% difference in measured biomass.

    The Mediterranean case study presented a different narrative. A less consistent performance was observed here due to larger densities and higher share of small diameter trees; larger densities increased surveyor errors whereas small diameter trees posed a challenge for the built-in laser scanner. Here, traditional methods required 54 minutes whereas Arboreal only required 30 minutes. However, a 27% underestimation by Arboreal was observed.

    Overall, accuracy improved with tree size, and efficiency gains were particularly pronounced in environments with large-diameter trees.

    Arboreal Forest as an alternative?

    The use of high-tech applications in forestry is increasing. The introduction of Terrestrial Laser Scanning systems in the forestry sector was met with enthusiasm due to the numerous possibilities and advantages they could offer. However, the price tag, weight and requirements of expertise for gathering and processing the collected data hindered widespread application of the technique. So, the search for alternative solutions continued. The introduction of laser scanning systems in mobile devices provided some solutions.

    Contrary to many other Mobile Laser Scanning applications, Arboreal Forest does not generate 3D point clouds, limiting co-registration errors and post-processing requirements. The collected data can be easily downloaded as .CSV files through Arboreal’s website, making the implementation of Arboreal in forest inventories even more user-friendly.

    Tips and tricks for in-field use

    1. In both case studies, we noted that both the accuracy and the efficiency of Arboreal Forest improved if a lower Diameter at Breast Height (DBH) threshold was applied. We recommend setting the lower limit to 7 cm.
    2. Trees growing perpendicular to steep slopes can pose a challenge for Arboreal Forest. As per good inventory practices, the DBH should be measured from the uphill side of the tree. Slanted trees should be measured from the side from/to which they grow.
    3. Arboreal Forest allows DBH measurements of irregularly shaped trees from two different viewpoints. From our experience, this practice resulted in a more accurate DBH assessment for irregularly shaped trees.
    4. Using technology for fieldwork brings along an important challenge: battery life. In this study, the iPad’s battery would survive about half a day before recharging was required. We recommend having a least 20% battery charge remaining before starting a new plot, of course depending on forest metrics such as tree density. We recommend bringing an appropriate power bank.

    Conclusions

    The Arboreal Forest app emerged as a viable option for forest inventories, offering significant time savings and cost-effectiveness, particularly in mature, regular stands. Recommendations for optimizing its usage include implementing a lower DBH threshold (7 cm) and avoiding its use in young, dense, and highly diverse forest stands. Our research contributes valuable insights into the application of mobile laser scanning systems in forestry and underscores Arboreal Forest’s potential to improve inventory practices and efficiency, aiding in climate change mitigation efforts.